Currently watching Most Haunted Top 50, or whatever it’s called, on LivingTV. They’re showing a countdown of the fifty greatest moments from the series and there’s a collection of soap actors and random people like models recounting what happens in each moment. At first I thought that these people had been involved in the clips, but it turns out that, no, in fact they’re actually just describing what happened after watching it on TV.
Now, as someone who’s just graduated with a science degree, I’m sure you can guess at my opinion of the things that happen on the show: I’m a little bit of a sceptic.
The best ones are the “possessions” when someone channels the voice of some spirit (usually Derek: right now they’re showing a clip of him strapped into a chair twitching and shaking). However, they just showed one where Yvette Fielding fainted after a séance (is that how it’s spelt?) and everyone was terrified so they picked her up and carried her out of the room and sat her down presumably until she regained conscoiusness.
Well, aside from how healthy it is to be doing things regularly that terrify you to the extent that you faint, the worst thing that you can do when someone faints is keep them upright. Fainting is your body trying to make you lie down to let blood get to your brain. It just seems that being around all these mysterious goings on has made people forget common sense.
The best thing was the way it was all presented as if it was really normal and everyday. I actually think that’s a bit wrong. You see these chat shows where some guy goes round telling people that people who have died have special messages for them, or you hear about someone who’s done a séance only to hear that they’ll die in a week — and then they do, by coincidence. How terrible must that be for the people who were at the séance?
Derren Brown, as much as I might find him a little annoying, did an excellent show where a group of people went through the whole séance experience, with spirits being channelled and everything, and the entire thing was him doing his usual mindtricks. He planted the ideas in their heads all along, and totally manipulated the whole thing. Now, I don’t know if a similar thing happens in these paranormal experiences (I would guess that most “mediums” don’t have Derren’s skills), but it does show that it’s possible to fake them very convincingly.
The rational explanation would be that it’s all the power of suggestion, the crowd mentality and fear making people see things that they don’t (but secretly do) want to see.
There’s a quote that’s relevant here, I think:
When people stop believing in God, they don’t believe in nothing — they believe in anything.
GK Chesterton